top of page


How traditionalism misrepresents the priesthood
Being born and raised in traditionalist communities, I had a view of the priesthood that I now realize was very skewed. And as I've thought about it over time, I've also come to realize how it may have affected my view of a potential calling to the priesthood. Although I discerned that I was not called and am very happily married, I can't help but wonder if my discernment process was affected by my understanding of the priesthood and how it was presented to me in the communit

Andrew Mioni
2 days ago5 min read


A.D. 2026: The Year of St. Francis, the SSPX, and Church Renewal
The recent announcements from both the SSPX and the Holy See about the impending episcopal consecrations have ignited a fresh wave of digital melees. Speculations, opinions, and even accusations abound on the decision, the declared potential consequences, and the perceived legitimacy of these consequences. And there's no denying this is an event of monumental significance in the Church. It's one that will objectively have a huge impact on the historical trajectory of both the

Andrew Mioni
Feb 214 min read
An Open Letter to Kennedy Hall
Mr. Hall, I am writing this letter in response to your recent publication in Crisis Magazine, The SSPX, the Truth, and Charity . Now, to be quite honest, I'm not a fan of the all-too-prevalent format of discourse that dominates Catholic internet today, which takes the form of one person responding in an incendiary manner to an article, video, etc from another content creator, leading to a spiral of response videos that ultimately do nothing more than drum up agitation and fru

Andrew Mioni
Feb 65 min read


Servants of the Holy Family— a preview of the SSPX's future?
The Servants of the Holy Family, an SSPX offshoot group, have been the subject of recent developments from the Vatican after their founder was consecrated a bishop in early 2024 without a pontifical mandate, incurring excommunication. Noting the almost identical parallels between them and the SSPX, I thought it might be worth examining their history, their current status, what they might indicate regarding how the Church intends to deal with the SSPX when they also consecrate

Andrew Mioni
Dec 31, 20254 min read


Rome will not approve new bishops for the SSPX. Here's why.
How the May 5, 1988 protocol with Lefebvre sets the standard for the future.

Andrew Mioni
Dec 28, 20258 min read


TLM and Novus Ordo: Offerings of Cain and Abel?
What makes a sacrifice more pleasing to God; the external elements or our interior disposition?

Andrew Mioni
Sep 14, 20257 min read
Against Radical Traditionalism: Lateran Council V, Session 11: On Preaching
We have learnt from trustworthy sources that some preachers in our times (we record this with sorrow)...are preaching many and various...

Andrew Mioni
Sep 9, 20255 min read


Against Radical Traditionalism: "Charitas" (1791) - Pope Pius VI
On those who were unlawfully consecrated bishops, and their lack of jurisdiction and authority.

Andrew Mioni
Aug 12, 20256 min read


God is Not a Tyrant: Reclaiming the Beauty of Redemptive Suffering through the Saints
By: Michelle De Berardinis When I first left the SSPX, I was spiritually disoriented. I found myself wrestling with confusion, fear, and...

MrsHappyCatholic
Jun 25, 20258 min read


Against Radical Traditionalism: "Etsi Multa" (1873) - Pope Bl. Pius IX
On the unlawful consecration and election of a bishop, and the subsequent penalties for him and his followers

Andrew Mioni
May 1, 20254 min read


Against Radical Traditionalism: "Satis Cognitum" (1896) - Pope Leo XIII
On the unity of the church and the authority of the pope and bishops

Andrew Mioni
May 1, 20255 min read


Against Radical Traditionalism: "Tribus Circiter" (1906) - Pope St Pius X
On a society of priests who promoted piety but devolved into an independent ministry and separated themselves from the lawful authorities

Andrew Mioni
Apr 30, 20253 min read


Against Radical Traditionalism: "Pieni L'Animo" (1906) - Pope St. Pius X
On "the spirit of insubordination and independence displayed among the clergy"

Andrew Mioni
Apr 30, 20253 min read


Some Questions on Marriages in the SSPX (pre-2015)
The question of supplied jurisdiction as it relates to the sacrament of Matrimony is one of the more contentious topics in traditionalist...

Andrew Mioni
Jan 27, 20255 min read
Did Vatican II really reverse the ends of marriage?
I can recall being told in my SSPX marriage classes that we “should have nothing to do with the Novus Ordo” because “they reversed the...

Andrew Mioni
Jan 12, 20254 min read


"Is it worth Communion?"
When I had recently left the SSPX, my husband and I were attending the FSSP parish about 10 minutes away from where I grew up. I had...

Clelia Mioni
Dec 20, 202410 min read
On the Journey Home: Part 2 - by Gary Campbell
Traditionalism isn’t a very confident religion. That may seem a counter-intuitive observation, given the boldness of traditionalists on...

MrsHappyCatholic
Dec 8, 20243 min read


On the Journey Home: Part 1 - by Gary Campbell
A quarter of a century ago I made the decision to leave the Society of St Pius X, after 12 years, five of them as a priest. I won’t go...

MrsHappyCatholic
Nov 9, 20243 min read


The Fatal Flaw of Sedevacantism
I will grant the sedevacantists one thing- they at least have the intellectual honesty to admit that the Recognize and Resist position...

Andrew Mioni
Nov 2, 20244 min read
Why I Left the SSPX: Fr. Robert Neville
Note from Trad Recovery: Our series "Why I Left the SSPX" is a collection of letters from priests who have left the SSPX over the years...

MrsHappyCatholic
Sep 26, 202411 min read
bottom of page
